Validity of Colposcopy in the Diagnosis of Early Cervical Neoplasia – A Review
Abstract
This study was conducted to quantify by meta-analysis the validity of colposcopy in the diagnosis of early cervical neoplasia in order to assess the justification of its integral role in this regard. Eight longitudinal studies were selected, which compared correlation of colposcopic impression with colposcopically directed biopsy results. The prevalence of disease in the studies ranged from 40 to 89%. Colposcopic accuracy was 89%, which agreed exactly with histology in 61% of cases. The sensitivity and specificity of colposcopy for the threshold normal versus all cervical abnormalities were 87–99% and 26–87% respectively. For the threshold normal and low grade SIL versus high grade SIL, the values were 30–90% and 67–97%. Likelihood ratios increased with disease severity. Colposcopy performed better in differentiation of high grade from low grade disease than in differentiation of low grade disease from normal cervix. Colposcopy is a valid tool for the diagnosis of early cervical neoplasia. Its integral role in the management of early cervical disease is justified. (Afr J Reprod Health 2002; 6[3]: 59–69)
Keywords: Colposcopy, cervical intraepithelial neoplasia, cervical cancer, colposcopic accuracy
Full Text:
XMLReferences
Hinselmann H. Verbesserung der inspektionsmög-lichkeiten von vulva, vagina und portio. Münch Med Wschr 1925; 1733.
Papanicolaou GN and Traut HF. The diagnostic value of vaginal smears in carcinoma of the uterus. Am J GynecolObset 1941; 42: 193.
Wespi H. Early Carcinoma of the Uterine Cervix: Pathogenesis and Detection. New York: Grune and Stratton, 1949.
Day NE. Effect of cervical cancer screening in Scandinavia. ObstetGynecol 1984; 63: 714–718.
Hakama M. Trends in the incidence of cervical cancer in the Nordic countries. In: Magnus K (Ed.). Trends in cancer incidence, causes and practical implications. Washington DC: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, 1988; 279–292.
Giles JA, Hudson E, Crow J, Williams D and Walker P. Colposcopic assessment of the accuracy of cervical cytology screening. Br Med J 1988; 296: 1099–1102.
Pairwuti S. False negative Papanicolaou smears from women with cancerous and precancerous lesions of the uterine cervix. ActaCytol 1991; 35: 40–46.
Kristensen GB, Skyggebjerg KD, Holund B, Holm K and Hansen MK. Analysis of cervical smears obtained within three years of the diagnosis of invasive cervical cancer. ActaCytol 1991; 35: 47–50.
Wain GV, Farnsworth A and Hacker NF. The Papanicolaou smear histories of 237 patients with cervical cancer. Med J Austr 1992; 157: 14–16.
Kos LG. Cervical (Pap) smear. Cancer 1993; 71: 1406–1412.
Joste NE, Crum CP and Cibas ES. Cytopathologic/ histologic correlation for quality control in cervicovaginal cytology: experience with 1,582 paired cases. Am J ClinPathol 1995; 103: 32–34.
Dodd LG, Sneige N, Villareal Y, et al. Quality assurance study of simultaneously sampled, non-correlating cervical cytology and biopsies. DiagnCytopathol 1993; 103: 32–34.
Stafl A and Mattingly RF. Colposcopic diagnosis of cervical neoplasia. ObstetGynecol 1973; 41: 168–76.
Ronk DA, Jimerson GK and Merrill JA. Evaluation of abnormal cervical cytology. ObstetGynecol 1977; 49: 581–6.
Kirby AJ, Spiegelhalter DJ, Day NE, et al. Conservative treatment of mild/moderate cervical dyskaryosis: long-term outcome. Lancet 1992; 339: 828–31.
Buxton EJ, Luesley DM, Shafi MI and Rollason M. Colposcopically directed punch biopsy: a potentially misleading investigation. Br J ObstetGynaecol 1991; 98: 1273–1276.
Benedet JL, Anderson GH and Boydes DA. Colposcopic accuracy in the diagnosis of microinvasive and occult invasive carcinoma of the cervix. ObstetGynecol 1985; 65: 557–562.
Hilgarth M and Menton M. The colposcopic screening. Eur J ObstetGynecolReprodBiol 1996; 65: 65–69.
Powell WS and Mckenzie HJ. Abnormal Papanicolaou smears. Comparison of cytology, colposcopy and cervical swab DNA hybridization. J Rep Med 1992; 37: 525–8.
Olatunbosun OA, Okonofua FE and Ayangade SO. Screening for cervical neoplasia in an African population: Simultaneous use of cytology and colposcopy. Int J GynecolObstet 1991; 36: 497–8.
Allahverdian V, Valaitis J, Kalis O and Pearlman S. Cytology and colposcopy in the diagnosis and management of outpatients with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. J Rep Med 1980; 24: 1–4.
Cartwright PS, Dao AH and Reed GW. Human papillomavirus in women. A three-year experience in a county hospital colposcopy clinic. J Rep Med 1992; 37: 167–9.
Etherington IJ, Dunn J, Shafi MI, Smith T and Luesley DM. Video colpography: a new technique for secondary cervical screening. Br J ObstetGynaecol 1997; 104: 150–153.
Daron GF and Miller MD. Colposcopic accuracy in a residency training program: defining competency and proficiency. J FamPract 1993; 36: 515–520.
Benedet JL, Boyes DA, Nichols TM and Millner A. Colposcopic evaluation of patients with abnormal cervical cytology. Br J ObstetGynaecol 1976; 83: 177–182.
Javaheri G and Fejgin MD. Diagnostic value of colposcopy in the investigation of cervical neoplasia. Am J ObstetGynecol 1980; 137: 588–594.
Edebiri AA. The relative significance of colposcopic descriptive appearances in the diagnosis of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. Int J GynecolObstet 1990; 33: 23–29.
Seshadri L, Jairaj P and Krisnashwami H. Colposcopy in the diagnosis of cervical neoplasia. Ind J Cancer 1990; 27: 180– 186.
Benedet JL, Anderson GH, Matisic JP and Miller DM. A quality control program for colposcopy practice. ObstetGynecol 1991; 78: 872–875.
Higgins RV, Hall JB, McGee JA, Laurent S, Alvarez RD and Partridge EE. Appraisal of the modalities used to evaluate an initial abnormal Papanicolaou smear. ObstetGynecol 1994; 84: 174–178.
Kierkegaard O, Byrjalsen C, Frandsen KH, Hansen KC and Frydenberg M. Diagnostic accuracy of cytology and colposcopy in cervical squamous intraepithelial lesions. ActaObstetGynecolScand 1994; 73: 648–651.
Cristoforoni PM, Gerbaldo D, Perino A, Piccoli R, Montz FJ and Capitanio GL. Computerized colposcopy: Results of a pilot study and analysis of its clinical relevance. ObstetGynecol 1995; 85: 1011–1016.
National Cancer Institute Workshop: the 1988 Bethesda system for reporting cervical/vaginal cytological diagnosis. JAMA 1989; 262: 931–934.
Jaeschke R, Guyatt G and Sackett DL. Users' guides to the medical literature III. How to use an article about a diagnostic test. Are the results of the study valid? JAMA 1994; 271: 389–91.
Jaeschke R, Guyatt G and Sackett DL. Users' guides to the medical literature III. How to use an article about a diagnostic test. B. What are the results and will they help me in caring for my patients? JAMA 1994; 271: 703–7.
Beller FK and Khatamee M. Evaluation of punch biopsy of the cervix under direct colposcopic observation (target punch biopsy). ObstetGynecol 1966; 28: 622–625.
Donohue LR and Meriwether W. Colposcopy as a diagnostic tool in the investigation of cervical neoplasias. Am J ObstetGynecol 1972; 113: 107–110.
Ortiz R and Newton M. Colposcopy in the management of abnormal cervical smears in pregnancy. Am J ObstetGynecol 1971; 109: 46–49.
Krumholz BA and Knapp RC. Colposcopic selection of biopsy sites. ObstetGynecol 1972; 39: 22–26.
Baldauf JJ, Dreyfuss M, Ritter J and Phillipe E. An analysis of the factors involved in the diagnosic accuracy of colposcopically directed biopsy. ActaObstetGynecolScand 1997; 76: 468–473.
Jordan JA. Colposcopy in the diagnosis of cervical cancer and precancer. ClinObstetGynecol 1985; 12: 67–76.
Kolstad P and Stafl A. Atlas of Colposcopy. Third Edition. Oslo: Universitetsforlaget, 1982.
Kurman RJ, Henson D, Herbert A, Noller K and Schiffman MH. Interim guidelines for management of abnormal cervical cytology. JAMA 1994; 271: 1866–9.
Coppleson M. The origin and nature of premalignant lesions of the cervix uteri. Int J GynecolObstet1970; 108: 539–550.
Reid R, Crum CP, Herschman BR, et al. Genital warts and cervical cancer. V. The true basis of colposcopic change. Am J ObstetGynecol 1984; 49: 293–303.
Rome RM, Urcuyo R and Nelson JH. Observations on the surface area of the abnormal transformation zone associated with intraepithelial and early invasive squamous cell lesions of the cervix. Am J ObstetGynecol 1977; 129: 565–70.
Homesley HD, Jobson BW and Reish RL. Use of colposcopically directed four quadrant biopsy by the colposcopy trainee. J Reprod Med 1984; 29: 311–316.
Richart RM, Crum CP and Townsend DE. Work-up of the patient with an abnormal Pap smear. GynecolOncol 1981; 12: 3264–76.
Ismail SM, Colclough AB, Dinnen JS, et al. Observer variation in histopathological diagnosis and grading of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. BMJ 1989; 296: 172.
Mitchell MF, Cantor SB, Ramanujam N, Tortolero-Luna and Richards-Kortum R. Flourescence spectroscopy for diagnosis of squamous intraepithelial lesions of the cervix. ObstetGynecol 1999; 93: 462–70.
Tovell HM, Banogan P and Nash AD. Cytology and colposcopy in diagnosis and management of preclinical carcinoma of cervix uteri: a learning experience. Am J ObstetGynecol 1976; 924–31.
Rochelson B and Krumholz BA. The unsatisfactory colposcopic examination. J Reprod Med 1983; 28: 131–5.
Drescher CW, Peters WA and Roberts JA. Contribution of endocervical curettage in evaluating abnormal cervical cytology. ObstetGynecol 1983; 62: 343–7.
Shingleton HM, Gore H and Austin JM. Outpatient evaluation of patients with atypical papanicolaou smears: contribution of endocervical curettage. Am J ObstetGynecol 1976; 126: 122–8.
Townsend DE and Richart RM. Diagnostic errors in colposcopy. GynecolOncol 1981; 12: S259–64.
Townsend DE, Ostergard DR, Mishell DR and Hirose FM. Abnormal Papanicolaou smears. Am J ObstetGynecol1970; 108: 429–434.
Seven B, Ford JH, Girtanner RD, et al. Invasive cancer of the cervix after cryosurgery. ObstetGynecol 1979; 53: 465–71.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.