Local perspectives on policy implementation of free maternity health services in Kenya: Implications for universal health coverage

Stephen O. Ombere, Erick O. Nyambedha, Tobias Haller, Sonja Merten

Abstract

Kenya introduced free maternity services (FMS) in 2013 to enable all pregnant women to give birth for free in all government public health facilities. Currently, Kenya is rolling out universal health coverage (UHC), which has been acknowledged as a priority goal for every health system and part of the ‘Big Four Agenda’ for sustainable national development in Kenya. FMS is one of the core services in Kenya, but since its launch, it is not clear whether the decentralized approach chosen to implement FMS is leading to UHC. This nine-month ethnographic study in Kilifi County, Kenya, was conducted between March-July 2016 and FebruaryJuly 2017. A narrative approach to analysis was applied. In this article, we interrogate local perceptions of participation during the crafting and implementation of FMS. Findings show that FMS was detached from local realities, and this was a major inadequacy of the top to bottom approach. FMS did not consider local power relations and bargaining power which are requisites during policy formulation and implementation. The participants expressed desire for more localized control over resources from the national government. The findings suggest that as UHC is rolled out in Kenya, consultation of local stakeholders at the grassroots by the state departments would likely improve maternal healthcare outcomes. Such consultations must take into consideration differences in bargaining power and local power relations. Borrowing from the basic tenets of the recent anthropological theorization of constitutionality, this article proposes a bottom to top approach that leverages and integrates local views during policy-making process to create trust, a sense of ownership and accountability. (Afr J Reprod Health 2023; 27 [5s]: 71-81).

Full Text:

PDF

References

Obermeyer M. The Cultural Context of Reproductive

Health : Implications for Monitoring the Cairo

Agenda The Cultural Context of Reproductive

Health : Implications for Monitoring the Cairo

Agenda. 25, (2018).

Obermeyer, M. Cultural perspectives on reproductive

health. (Oxford University Press, Inc., 2001).

Ombere SO. Local Perceptions of Social Protection

Schemes in Maternal Health in Kenya : Ethnography

in Coastal Kenya (PhD Thesis). PhD Thesis (2018).

Ombere SO, Haller T and Nyambedha E. Cultural Practices

During Pregnancy and Birth Among the Giriama

Community in Coastal Kenya : A Qualitative Study.

Int. J. Childbirth 11, 154–165 (2021).

Atchessi N, Ridde V and Zunzunegui MV. User fees

exemptions alone are not enough to increase

indigent use of healthcare services. Health Policy

Plan. 31, (2016).

Bolsewicz AK, Hipgrave D and Jimenez-Soto E. Public

Engagement in Health Priority Setting in Low- and

Middle-Income Countries: Current Trends and

Considerations for Policy. PLoS Med. 10, 8–10

(2013).

Kamuzora P, Maluka S, Ndawi B, Byskov J and Hurtig AK.

Promoting community participation in priority

setting in district health systems: experiences from

Mbarali district, Tanzania. Glob. Health Action 6,

(2013).

Salter B. Patients and doctors: Reformulating the UK health

policy community? Soc. Sci. Med. 57, 927–936

(2003).

Coleman W and Pearl A. Internationalized Policy

Environments and Policy Network Analysis. Polit.

Stud. 47, 691–709 (1999).

Munge K and Briggs AH. The progressivity of health-care

financing in Kenya. 912–920 (2014)

doi:10.1093/heapol/czt073.

Mwabu GM and Mwangi WM. Healthcare financing in

Kenya: A simulation of welfare effects of user fees.

Soc. Sci. Med. 22, 763–767 (1986).

World Health Organization (WHO). Health financing

reform in Kenya: assessing the social health

insurance proposal (No. EIP/HSF/DP. 06.1).

(2006).

Owuor HO, Asito SA and Adoka SO. The differential

effect of the free maternity services policy in Kenya.

African J. Prim. Heal. Care Fam. Med. 11, 1–6

(2019).

National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF). Linda Mama

Services.

http://www.nhif.or.ke/healthinsurance/lindamamaS

ervices (2016).

Masaba BB and Mmusi-Phetoe RM. Free Maternal

Healthcare Policy in Kenya; Level of Utilization and Barriers. Int. J. Africa Nurs. Sci. 13, 100234 (2020).

Sidze EM. Kenya maternity fee waiver is great - but there

are still gaps in the policy. (2017).

Ochieng BM, Kaseje M, Kaseje DCO, Oria K and Magadi

M. Perspectives of stakeholders of the free maternity

services for mothers in western Kenya: lessons for

universal health coverage. BMC Health Serv. Res.

, 1–18 (2022).

Pyone T, Smith H and Van Den Broek N. Implementation

of the free maternity services policy and its

implications for health system governance in Kenya.

BMJ Glob. Heal. 2, 1–11 (2017).

Okungu V, Chuma J and Mcintyre D. The cost of free

healthcare for all Kenyans : assessing the financial

sustainability of contributory and non-contributory

financing mechanisms. 1–13 (2017)

doi:10.1186/s12939-017-0535-9.

Gitobu CM, Gichangi PB and Mwanda WO. The effect of

Kenya’s free maternal health care policy on the

utilization of health facility delivery services and

maternal and neonatal mortality in public health

facilities. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 18, 1–11

(2018).

Lee E, Madhavan S and Bauhoff S. Levels and variations

in the quality of facility-based antenatal care in

Kenya: Evidence from the 2010 service provision

assessment. Health Policy Plan. 31, 777–784

(2016).

Muinde JVS and Prince RJ. A new universalism?

Universal health coverage and debates about rights,

solidarity and inequality in Kenya. Soc. Sci. Med.

(2022)

doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2022.115258.

Chrispinus T and Ltumbesi S. Analysis of Universal Health

Coverage and Equity on Health Care in Kenya.

Glob. J. Health Sci. 8, 218–227 (2015).

Chuma J and Okungu V. Viewing the Kenyan health

system through an equity lens: Implications for

universal coverage. Int. J. Equity Health 10, 1–14

(2011).

Barasa E, Rogo K, Mwaura N and Chuma J. Kenya

national hospital insurance fund reforms:

Implications and lessons for universal health

coverage. Heal. Syst. Reform 4, 346–361 (2018).

World Health Organization (WHO). Universal health

coverage (UHC). https://www.who.int/newsroom/fact-sheets/detail/universal-health-coverage-

(uhc) (2019).

World Health Organization (WHO). WHO

recommendations on health promotion interventions

for maternal and newborn health 2015. (2015).

Mulupi S, Kirigia D and Chuma J. Community perceptions

of health insurance and their preferred design

features : implications for the design of universal

health coverage reforms in Kenya. (2013).

World Health Organization (WHO). Tracking universal

health coverage. 2017 global monitoring report.

(2017).

Chuma J and Okungu V. Viewing the Kenyan health

system through an equity lens: Implications for

universal coverage. Int. J. Equity Health 10, 1–14

(2011).

Chuma J and Maina T. Catastrophic health care spending

and impoverishment in Kenya. BMC Heal. Serv.

Res. 1–9 (2012).

Wagstaff A. Measuring financial protection in health.

Perform. Meas. Heal. Syst. Improv. Exp. Challenges

Prospect. 114–137 (2008)

doi:10.1017/CBO9780511711800.006.

Whitehead M, Dahlgren G and Evans T. Equity and health

sector reforms: Can low-income countries escape

the medical poverty trap? Lancet 358, 833–836

(2001).

Kenya National Bureau of Statistics (KNBS). 2019 Kenya

Population and Housing Census Volume 1:

Population by County and Sub-County. vol. I

(Kenya National Bureau of Statistics, 2019).

Kenya National Bureau of Statistics & ICF International.

Kenya 2014 Demographic and Health Survey Key

Findings. vol. 6 (KNBS and ICF International,

.

Republic of Kenya. Status of implementation of free

maternity services (FMS) program in the devolved

health system in Kenya. (Ministry of Health, 2015).

Tama E, Molyneux S, Waweru E, Tsofa B, Chuma J and

Barasa E. Examining the Implementation of the Free

Maternity Services Policy in Kenya: A Mixed

Methods Process Evaluation. Int. J. Heal. Policy

Manag. 7, 603–613 (2018).

Wamalwa E, Osuga B and Adoyo M. Implementation of

Free Maternity Services Policy in Kenya: Health

Workers’ Attitude and Involvement. 1, 5986240–

(2015).

Meessen B, Hercot D, Noirhomme M and Bicaba A.

Removing user fees in the health sector in lowincome countries : a multi-country review. (2017).

Minkler, M. Community-based research partnerships:

Challenges and opportunities. J. Urban Heal. 82, 3–

(2005).

Loewenson R, Flores W, Shukla A, Kagis M, Baba A,

Ryklief A, Mbwili-Muleya C and Kakde D. Raising

the profile of participatory action research at the

global symposium on health systems research.

MEDICC Rev. 13, 35–38 (2011).

Kamanda A, Embleton L, Ayuku D, Atwoli L, Gisore P,

Ayaya S, Vreeman R and Braitstein P. Harnessing

the power of the grassroots to conduct public health

research in sub-Saharan Africa : a case study from

western Kenya in the adaptation of communitybased participatory research ( CBPR ) approaches.

(2013).

Haller T and Merten S. Crafting Our Own Rules:

Constitutionality as a Bottom-Up Approach for the

development of By-Laws in Zambia. Hum. Ecol. 46,

–13 (2018).

Haller T, Acciaioli G and Rist S. Constitutionality:

Conditions for Crafting Local Ownership of

Institution-Building Processes. Soc. Nat. Resour. 29,

–87 (2016).

Mbugua S and Kerry M. Maternal Health Indicators in

High-Priority Counties of Kenya: Levels and

Inequities. DHS Further Analysis Reports No.110.

(ICF, 2018).

Braun V and Clarke V. Successful qualitative research: A

practical guide for beginners. (Sage, 2013).

Rifkin SB. Examining the links between community

participation and health outcomes: A review of the

literature. Health Policy Plan. 29, ii98–ii106 (2014).

Pratt B. Community engagement in global health research

that advances health equity. 454–463 (2018)

doi:10.1111/bioe.12465.

Pratt B. Inclusion of Marginalized Groups and

Communities in Global Health Research PrioritySetting. J. Empir. Res. Hum. Res. Ethics 14, 169–

(2019).

Ferguson J. The Anti-Politics Machine: “Development,”

Depoliticization, and Bureaucratic Power in

Lesotho. (University of Minnesota Press, 1996).

Siddiqui FR. Annotated bibliography on participatory

consultations to help aid the inclusion of

marginalized perspectives in setting policy agendas.

Int. J. Equity Health 13, 1–16 (2014).

Rifkin SB. Paradigms Lost: Toward a new understanding

of community participation in health programmes.

Acta Trop. 61, 79–92 (1996).

Gilson L. Trust and the development of healthcare as a

social institution. Soc. Sci. Med. 56, 1453–1468

(2003).

Khan SH. Cost Effectiveness and Resource Free does not

mean affordable : maternity patient expenditures in

a public hospital in Bangladesh. 7, 1–7 (2005).

Nabyonga OJ, Mugisha F, Kirunga C, MacQ J and Criel B.

Abolition of user fees: The Uganda paradox. Health

Policy Plan. 26, (2011).

Kruk ME, Mbaruku G, Rockers PC and Galea S. User fee

exemptions are not enough: Out-of-pocket payments

for ‘free’ delivery services in rural Tanzania. Trop.

Med. Int. Heal. 13, 1442–1451 (2008).

Ombere, S. Access to Maternal Health Services During the

COVID-19 Pandemic: Experiences of Indigent

Mothers and Health Care Providers in Kilifi County,

Kenya. Front. Sociol. 6, 1–8 (2021).

Dalinjong PA, Wang AY and Homer CSE. Has the free

maternal health policy eliminated out of pocket

payments for maternal health services? Views of

women, health providers and insurance managers in

Northern Ghana. PLoS One 13, 1–19 (2018).

Kehr J, Muinde JV and Prince RJ. Health for all? Pasts,

presents and futures of aspirations for universal

healthcare. Soc. Sci. Med. 115660 (2023)

doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2023.115660.

Prince R. Beyond Failure. Soc. Anthropol. Soc. 30, 56–80

(2022).

Faye P, Haller T and Ribot J. Shaping Rules and Practice

for More Justice. Local Conventions and Local

Resistance in Eastern Senegal. Hum. Ecol. 46, 15–

(2018).

Haller T, Acciaioli G and Rist S. Constitutionality:

Conditions for Crafting Local Ownership of

Institution-Building Processes. Soc. Nat. Resour. 29,

–87 (2016).

Ensminger, J. Making a market: The institutional

transformation of an African society. (Cambridge

University Press, 1996).

Chataway CJ. An examination of the constraints on mutual

inquiry in a participatory action research project. J.

Soc. Issues 53, 747–765 (1997).

Fourie DJ. Mechanisms to improve citizen participation in

government and its administration. South African J.

Econ. Manag. Sci. 4, 216–233 (2001)

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.