Co-creating gender-transformative interventions for adolescent mental, sexual, and reproductive health and rights: Influence of context and actors on process and content in Niger, Ghana, and Burkina Faso

Lauren J. Wallace, Natasha A. Darko, Aissa Diarra, Maurice Yaogo, Bernice Gyawu, Priscilla Prempeh, Emelia A. Agblevor, Ann-Michelle Darko, Tolib Mirzoev, Irene A. Agyepong

Abstract

This paper explores how context and actors influence processes and content efforts to co-create gender transformative primary health care systems for adolescents in West Africa and draws out lessons for co-creation of effective adolescent mental, sexual, and reproductive health and rights (AMSRHR) interventions in low and middle income countries. The study design was a multicountry case study with the case defined as "processes, context, actors and content of co-creation of gender-transformative adolescent mental, sexual, and reproductive health interventions". Data are from mixed qualitative sources in two research phases:
a situational/context analysis and co-creation/data validation workshops. Findings reveal that while national AMSRHR policies promote gender-sensitive approaches, actual programmes remain largely gender-neutral or gender-blind. Important considerations in co-creating AMSRHR interventions include how to effectively engage powerful stakeholders with diverse positions, pay attention to gendered power imbalances in co-creation processes, and raise critical consciousness of complex AMSRHR issues through non-threatening, participatory approaches.

Full Text:

PDF

References

Rutter M. Pathways from childhood to adult life. Journal of

Child

psychology

and

Psychiatry.

Jan;30(1):23-51.

Sawyer SM, Afifi RA, Bearinger LH, Blakemore SJ, Dick

B, Ezeh AC and Patton GC. Adolescence: a

foundation for future health. The Lancet. 2012, Apr

;379(9826):1630-40.

Zaba B, Pisani E, Slaymaker E and Boerma JT. Age at first

sex:

understanding recent trends in African

demographic

surveys.

Sexually

Transmitted

Infections. 2004,Dec 1;80(suppl 2):28-35.

Bearinger LH, Sieving RE, Ferguson J and Sharma V. Global

perspectives on the sexual and reproductive health of

adolescents: patterns, prevention, and potential. The

Lancet. 2007 Apr 7;369(9568):1220-31.

Weis JR and Greene JA. Mental health in pregnant

adolescents: focus on psychopharmacology. The

Journal of Pediatrics. 2016 Feb 1;169:297-304.

Forhan SE, Gottlieb SL, Sternberg MR, Xu F, Datta SD,

McQuillan GM, Berman SM and Markowitz LE.

Prevalence of sexually transmitted infections among

female adolescents aged 14 to 19 in the United States.

Pediatrics. 2009 Dec 1;124(6):1505-12.

World Health Organization. Mental Health of Adolescents.

(2021).

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact

sheets/detail/adolescent-mental-health

Duby Z, McClinton Appollis T, Jonas K, Maruping K,

Dietrich J, LoVette A, Kuo C, Vanleeuw L and

Mathews C. “As a young pregnant girl… the

challenges you face”: exploring the intersection

between mental health and sexual and reproductive

health amongst adolescent girls and young women in

South Africa. AIDS and Behavior. 2021 Feb;25:344

Vanderkruik R, Gonsalves L, Kapustianyk G, Allen T and

Say L. Mental health of adolescents associated with

sexual and reproductive outcomes: a systematic

review. Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

May 5;99(5):359.

Diallo I, Aldridge LR, Bass J, Adams LB and Spira AP.

Factors associated with suicide in four West African

countries among adolescent students: an analysis

using the global school-based student health survey.

J Adolesc Health. 2023; 73(3): 494-502.

Izugbara C, Suubi K and Ingabire MG. Gender and

adolescent sexual and reproductive health and rights

in West and Central Africa: New evidence and

emerging gaps. African Journal of Reproductive

Health. 2024 Aug 30;28(8s):15.

Silverman JG, Challa S, Boyce SC, Averbach S and Raj A.

Associations of reproductive coercion and intimate

partner violence with overt and covert family

planning use among married adolescent girls in

Niger. E ClinicalMedicine. 2020 May 1;22.

Alatinga KA, Allou LA and Kanmiki EW. Contraceptive

use among migrant adolescent girl head porters in

Southern Ghana: policy implications for sexual and

reproductive health education and promotion.

Children and Youth Services Review. 2021 Jan

;120:105-651.

Bain LE, Zweekhorst MB and de Cock Buning T.

Prevalence and determinants of unintended

pregnancy in sub–saharan Africa: a systematic

review. African Journal of Reproductive Health.

Jul 24;24(2):187-205.

Misunas C, Erulkar A, Apicella L, Ngô T and Psaki S. What

influences girls' age at marriage in Burkina Faso and

Tanzania? Exploring the contribution of individual,

household, and community level factors. Journal of

Adolescent Health. 2021 Dec 1;69(6):S46-56.

Amoah E. Psychosocial experiences of pregnant

adolescents: A study at the Tema Metropolis

[Doctoral dissertation]. University of Ghana; 2013.

Available

from:

https://ugspace.ug.edu.gh/server/api/core/bitstreams

/2de175aa-e72d-4baa-8a30-35d7a0ce1ee2/content

Quarshie EN and Odame SK. Suicidal ideation and

associated factors among school-going adolescents

in rural Ghana. Current Psychology. 2021

Feb;42(1):505-518.

Sarfo EA, Salifu Yendork J and Naidoo AV. Understanding

child marriage in Ghana: The constructions of gender

and sexuality and implications for married girls.

Child Care in Practice. 2022 Apr 3;28(2):228-41.

Sikweyiya Y, Addo-Lartey AA, Alangea DO, Dako-Gyeke

P, Chirwa ED, Coker-Appiah D, Adanu RM and

Jewkes R. Patriarchy and gender-inequitable

attitudes as drivers of intimate partner violence

against women in the central region of Ghana. BMC

Public Health. 2020 Dec;20:1-1.

Beckwith S, Li M, Barker KM, Gayles J, Kågesten AE,

Lundgren R, Dintrans PV, Wilopo SA and Moreau

C. The impacts of two gender-transformative

interventions on early adolescent gender norms

perceptions: a difference-in-difference analysis.

Journal of Adolescent Health. 2023 Jul 1;73(1):55

Ruane-McAteer E, Gillespie K, Amin A, Aventin Á,

Robinson M, Hanratty J, Khosla R and Lohan M.

Gender-transformative programming with men and

boys to improve sexual and reproductive health and

rights: a systematic review of intervention studies.

BMJ Global Health. 2020 Oct 1;5(10):002997.

Fisher J and Makleff S. Advances in gender-transformative

approaches to health promotion. Annual Review of

Public Health. 2022 Apr 5;43(1):1-7.

World Health Organization. Engaging men, addressing

harmful masculinities to improve sexual and

reproductive health and rights. 2019.

https://www.who.int/news/item/26-09-2019

engaging-men-addressing-harmful-masculinities-to

improve-sexual-and-reproductive-health-and-rights

Boadu ES and Isioma I. Rethinking participation in

monitoring and evaluation. Beneficiaries’

perspectives from the Local Enterprises and Skills

Development Programme (LESDEP) in Ghana.

Loyola Journal of Social Sciences. 2017 Jul 1;31(2):

-227.

Mmari K, Simon C and Verma R. Gender-transformative

interventions for young adolescents: What have we

learned and where should we go? Journal of

Adolescent Health. 2024 Oct 1;75(4):62-80.

Brett JO, Staniszewska S, Mockford C, Herron-Marx S,

Hughes J, Tysall C and Suleman R. A systematic

review of the impact of patient and public

involvement on service users, researchers and

communities.

The

Patient-Patient-Centered

Outcomes Research. 2014 Dec;7:387-395.

Vargas C, Whelan J, Brimblecombe J and Allendera S. Co

creation, co-design and co-production for public

health: a perspective on definitions and distinctions.

Public Health Research & Practice. 2022 Jun 1;32(2).

Agrawal AK, Kaushik AK and Rahman Z. Co-creation of

social value through integration of stakeholders.

Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2015 May

;189:442-8.

Mbachu CO, Clara Agu I and Onwujekwe O. Collaborating

to co-produce strategies for delivering adolescent

sexual and reproductive health interventions:

processes and experiences from an implementation

research project in Nigeria. Health Policy and

Planning. 2020 Nov;35(Supplement_2):ii84-97.

Mannell J, Washington L, Khaula S, Khoza Z, Mkhwanazi

S, Burgess RA, Brown LJ, Jewkes R, Shai N, Willan

S and Gibbs A. Challenges and opportunities in

coproduction: reflections on working with young

people to develop an intervention to prevent violence

in informal settlements in South Africa. BMJ Global

Health. 2023 Mar 1;8(3):e011463.

Mukherjee A, Nair A and Ranjan R. Co-creating sexual and

reproductive health interventions with adolescents:

the experience from Rajasthan. International Journal

of Community Medicine and Public Health. 2023

Aug;10(8):3024.

Lofton S, Norr KF, Jere D, Patil C and Banda C.

Developing action plans in youth photovoice to

address community-level HIV risk in rural Malawi.

International Journal of Qualitative Methods. 2020

Apr 22;19.

Rolleri LA. Gender transformative programing in

adolescent

reproductive

and sexual health:

Definitions, strategies, and resources. Practice

Matters: Gender & Sexual Health Part Four. ACT for

Youth Center of Excellence. 2014 Jan.

Caro, D. A manual for integrating gender into reproductive

health and HIV programs: From commitment to

action (2nd ed.). Washington DC: Population

Reference Bureau. 2009.

Walt G and Gilson L. Reforming the health sector in

developing countries: the central role of policy

analysis. Health Policy and Planning. 1994 Dec

;9(4):353-70.

De Savigny D, Blanchet K and Adam T. Applied systems

thinking

for

health

systems

research:

a

methodological handbook. McGraw-Hill Education

(UK); 2017 Sep 16.

Marcus R and Harper C. Gender justice and social norms

processes of change for adolescent girls. London:

Overseas Development Institute. 2014 Jan.

Gomes A. Paulo Freire: Review of “The Pedagogy of the

Oppressed” 1st Edition, Penguin Random House

UK, London, 2017. Harm Reduction Journal. 2022

Mar 4;19(1):21.

Taboada A, Taggart T, Holloway I, Houpt A, Gordon R,

Gere D, Milburn N and Lightfoot AF. A critical

review of the characteristics of theater-based HIV

prevention interventions for adolescents in school

settings.

Health

Jul;17(4):537-47.

Promotion Practice. 2016

Taylor RD, Oberle E, Durlak JA and Weissberg RP.

Promoting positive youth development through

school‐based social and emotional learning

interventions: A meta‐analysis of follow‐up effects.

Child development. 2017 Jul;88(4):1156-71.

Ghana Health Service. Adolescent Health Service Policy

and Strategy 2016-2020. Accra: Ghana Health

Service; 2016.

Ministry of Health. Multisectoral National Strategic Plan

for Adolescent and Youth Health 2017-2021.

Niamey: Ministry of Health; 2017.

Ministry of Health. National Strategic Plan for the

Prevention of Teenage Pregnancy 2015-2020.

Niamey: Ministry of Health; 2015.

Ministry of Health. The Reproductive Health Plan of

Adolescents and Young People. Ouagadougou:

Ministry of Health; 2015.

National Assembly. Law on Reproductive Health.

Ouagadougou: National Assembly; 2005.

Cense M, Grauw SD, Vermeulen M. ‘Sex is not just about

ovaries.’Youth participatory research on sexuality

education in The Netherlands. International Journal

of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2020

Nov;17(22):8587.

Wood L and Hendricks F. A participatory action research

approach to developing youth-friendly strategies for

the prevention of teenage pregnancy. Educational

action research. 2017 Jan 1;25(1):103-18.

Lassi ZS, Neideck EG, Aylward BM, Andraweera PH and

Meherali S. Participatory action research for

adolescent sexual and reproductive health: a scoping

review. Sexes. 2022 Mar 3;3(1):189-208.

Longworth GR, Erikowa-Orighoye O, Anieto EM, Agnello

DM, Zapata-Restrepo JR, Masquillier C and Giné

Garriga M. Conducting co-creation for public health

in low and middle-income countries: a systematic

review and key informant perspectives on

implementation

barriers

and

facilitators.

Globalization and Health. 2024 Jan 17;20(1):9.

Bell S, Berg T and Morse S. Rich pictures: sustainable

development and stakeholders–the benefits of

content analysis. Sustainable Development. 2016

Mar;24(2):136-48.

Conte KP and Davidson S. Using a ‘rich picture’ to

facilitate systems thinking in research coproduction.

Health Research Policy and Systems. 2020 Dec;18:1-4.

Shahmanesh M, Okesola N, Chimbindi N, Zuma T, Mdluli

S, Mthiyane N, Adeagbo O, Dreyer J, Herbst C,

McGrath N and Harling G. Thetha Nami:

participatory development of a peer-navigator

intervention to deliver biosocial HIV prevention for

adolescents and youth in rural South Africa. BMC

Public Health. 2021 Dec;21:1-3.

Kaponda CP, Dancy BL, Norr KF, Kachingwe SI, Mbeba

MM and Jere DL. Community consultation to

develop an acceptable and effective adolescent HIV

prevention intervention. Journal of the Association of

Nurses in AIDS Care. 2007 Mar 1;18(2):72-7.

Backman-Levy JK and Greene ME. Gender-transformative

programmes: a framework for demonstrating

evidence of social impact. BMJ Global Health. 2024

May 1;9(5):e014203.

Freire P and Ramos M, translator. Pedagogy of the

Oppressed: 30th Anniversary Edition. New York:

The Continuum International Publishing Group Inc;

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.