Positive masculinity programmes and attitudes towards nonconforming gender identities among young males in urban Democratic Republic of Congo, Nigeria, and Rwanda

Kelechi Okpara, Christian Ngomenzey, Aloysius Odii, Chiemezie Atama, Jacques Emina, Ilaria Busgacalia, Fidèle Rutayisire, Chidi Ugwu, Ike Ernest Onyishi, Chimaraoke Izugbara

Abstract

Implementing programmes on sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) in sub-Saharan Africa often involves promoting inclusive sexual identity/orientation. However, whether and how the programmes are changing gender norms in the target populations have not been established. This study was designed to determine whether participation in Positive Masculinity (PM) programmes can change attitudes associated with prevailing gender norms. We explored attitudes towards nonconforming sexual identity/orientation among young males in selected informal settlements in Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), Nigeria and Rwanda. The key variables we tested included “country of participation” and other socio-demographics such as “education”, “marital status” and “prior residential location” (rural or urban). We found no significant association between participation in PM programmes with attitudes towards nonconforming sexual identities/orientations across our target populations irrespective of educational qualification, marital status, and previous location of residence. By contrast, religious teachings showed up in the qualitative responses as a significant factor influencing young people’s resistance to PM programmes’ advocating for inclusive sexuality. Additionally, negative masculinity attributes had significant negative association with attitudes towards nonconforming sexual identity, while respondents with violent tendencies showed significant positive attitudes. We conclude that current PM interventions do not significantly contribute to positive attitudes towards inclusive sexuality in DRC, Nigeria, and Rwanda. (Afr J Reprod Health 2024; 28 [8s]: 21-31).

Full Text:

PDF

References

Izugbara C. ‘We are the real men’: Masculinity, poverty,

health, and community development in the slums of

Nairobi, Kenya. Department of Social Work,

University of Gothenburg, Sweden, 2015.

Pérez-Martínez V, Marcos-Marcos J, Cerdán-Torregrosa

J, Briones-Vozmediano E, Sanz-Barbero B, Davó

Blanes M, Daoud N, Edwards C, Salazar M, La Parra

Casado, D, Vives-Cases C and Ogbu OG. Positive

masculinities and gender-based violence educational

interventions among young people: A systematic

review. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse. 2021; 20(10):

-19.

Ogbu OG. Gender, sexuality, and violence intervention:

sexual minorities in Nigeria. Peace Studies Journal.

; 13(2): 105-115.

Johnson K, Scott J, Rughita B, Kisielewski M, Asher J, Ong

R and Lawry L. Association of sexual violence and

human rights violations with physical and mental

health in territories of the Eastern Democratic

Republic of the Congo. JAMA. 2010; 304(5): 553-562.

Paszat E. The limits of LGBT rights in Rwanda: International

action and domestic erasure. New Political Science.

; 44(3): 424 – 438.

Gowen K and Winges-Yanez N. Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual,

Transgender, Queer, and Questioning youths’

perspectives of inclusive school-based sexuality

education. The Journal of Sex Research. 2013; 51(7):

-800.

Mule NJ, Boss LE, Deeprose B, Jackson BE, Daley A,

Travers A and Moore D. Promoting LGBT health and

wellbeing through inclusive policy development.

International Journal of Equity in Health. 2009;

(19): 1-11.

Graaff K. Reassessing masculinities-focused interventions:

Room and reasons for improvement. Social and

Health Sciences. 2021; 103 – 123.

Crone T and Stevenson J. Sexual and reproductive health and

rights (SRHR) and sexual orientation, gender, identity

and expression and sex characteristics. Summary

Report of 3rd MenEngage Global Symposium, 2021;

https://menengage.org/wp

content/uploads

/2022/02/SRHR-MenEngage-Ubuntu-Symposium

Discussion-Paper-EN.pdf

De Jesus DSV. Imploding the mirage: The Yogyakarta

principles and the new era of globalization.

Philosophy Study. 2022; 12(3): 162-166.

Park A. Yogyakarta Plus 10: A demand for recognition of

SOGIESC. NC Journal of International Law. 2019;

(2): 223 – 272.

Thoreson RR. Queering human rights: The Yogyakarta

Principles and the norm that dare nor speak its name.

Journal of Human Rights. 2009; 8(4): 323-339.

Holzer L. Smashing the binary? A new era of legal gender

registration in the Yogyakarta principles plus 10.

International Journal of Gender, Sexuality and Law.

; 98: 98-133.

Fabris L, Patch H and Schubert K. Liberalism and the

construction of gender (non-) normative bodies and

queer identities. Global contestations of gender rights.

Bielefeld University Press, 2022: 269-286.

Kuhar R and Paternotte D. Anti-gender campaigns in

Europe. Mobilising against equality. London; New

York: Rowman & Littlefield; 2017.

Vida B. New waves of anti-sexual and reproductive health

and rights strategies in the European union: the anti

gender discourse in Hungary. Sexual and reproductive

health matters. 2019; 27(2): 13-16.

Bem SL. The lenses of gender: Transforming the debate on

sexual inequality. New Haven, CT: Yale University

Press, 1993.

Crompton R and Lyonette C. The new gender essentialism

domestic and family ‘choices and their relation to

attitudes. The British journal of sociology. 2005;

(4): 601-620.

Delphy C. Rethinking sex and gender. Women’s Studies In.

Forum. 1993; 16(1): 1-9.

Gammel I. Sexualizing power in naturalism: Theodore

Dreiser and Frederick Philip Grove. Alberta:

University of Calgary Press, 1994.

Downie R. Revitalizing the fight against homophobia in

Africa. Washington: Center for Strategic &

International Studies, 2014.

Gloppen S and Rakner L. LGBT rights in Africa. In Ashford

C and Maine, A (Eds.). Research handbook on gender,

sexuality and the law. Norway: Centre on Law and

Social Transformation, 2020: 194-209.

Müller A, Daskilewicz K, Kabwe ML, Mmolai-Chalmers A,

Morroni C, Muparamoto N, Muula AS, Odira V and

Zimba M SEARCH. Experience of and factors

associated with violence against sexual and gender

minorities in nine African countries: a cross-sectional

study. BMC Public Health. 2021; 21: 357.

Ibrahim AM. LGBT rights in Africa and the discursive role

of international human rights law. African Human

Rights Law Journal, 2015; 15(2): 263-281.

Dreier SK, Long JD and Winkler S. African, religious, and

tolerant? How religious diversity shapes attitudes

towards sexual minorities in Africa. Politics and

Religion. 2019; 13(2): 1-31.

Izugbara C, Emina J, Ugwu C, Busgacalia I, Rutayisire F,

Atama C, Odii A, Okpara K, Ngomenzey C and Onyishi I. Positive masculinity programmes, gender

attitudes and practices, and health behaviours among

men and boys in poor urban settlements in Democratic

Republic of Congo, Nigeria, and Rwanda.

International Center for Research on Women,

Washing DC, USA; Population and Health Research

Institute, Kinshasa, DRC; Gender & Development

Studies

Research

Group,

Department

of

Sociology/Anthropology, University of Nigeria,

Nsukka, Nigeria; and The Rwanda Men’s Resource

Centre, Kigali, Rwanda, 2022.

Izugbara C, Tikkanen R and Barron K. Men, masculinity,

and community development in Kenya slums.

Community Dev. 2014; 45: 32-44.

Edström J, Izugbara C, Nesbitt-Ahmed Z, Otieno PE,

Granvik M and Matindi S. Men in collective action on

SGBV in Kenya: A case study. Evidence Report 70,

Brighton: IDS, 2014.

Angotti N, Mckay T and Robinson RS. LGBT visibility and

anti-gay backlash. Sociology of Development. 2019;

(1): 71-90

Poushter J and Kent N. The global divide on homosexuality

persists.

Pew

Research

Center,

https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2020/06/25/glob

al-divide-on-homosexuality-persists/

Badewa AS and Dinbabo MF. South Africa’s political

commitment to the promotion and protection of the

rights of vulnerable groups. In. I Ile and O Fagbadebo

(Eds.). Democracy and political governance in South

Africa: The African Peer Review Mechanism,

Springer, 2023: 99-112.

Laurah A. Margins within the marginalized: Violence and

access to justice of Lesbians, Bisexual and queer

women in Africa. In Budoo-Scholtz A and Lubaale

EC. Violence against women and criminal justice in

Africa II. Palgrave Macmillan: Springer, 2021.

Higa D, Hoppe, MJ, Lindhorst T, Mincer S, Beadnell B,

Morrison DM, Wells EA, Todd A and Mount S.

Negative and positive factors associated with the

wellbeing of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender,

queers, and questioning (LGBTQ) youth. Youth Soc.

; 46(5): 663-687.

Souza TC and Cribari-Neto F. Intelligence, religiosity and

homosexuality non-acceptance: Empirical evidence.

Intelligence. 2015; 52: 63-70.

Ling HN and Ting SH. Demographic factors influencing

tolerance towards LGBT individuals among

Malaysians. Human Behaviour, Development and

Society. 2022; 23(1).

Kozloski MJ. Assessing the demographics of homosexual

tolerance. (Department of Sociology, University of

Chicago). 2012

Palm S. Religion, gender norms and campus rape culture:

Building resistance from below. Politeia. 2018; 37(2):

-19.

Piper KN, Fuller TJ, Ayers AA, Lambert DN, Sales JM and

Wingood GM. A qualitative exploration of religion,

gender norms, and sexual decision-making within

African American faith-based communities. Sex

Roles. 2019; 82: 189-205.

Rule S and Mncwango B. “Christianity in South Africa:

Theory and practice.” In B Roberts, M waKivilu, YD

Davies (Eds.). South African social attitudes: The 2nd

Report. Reflections on the Age of Hope. Cape Town:

HSRC Press, 2010: 185–98.

Brimmer J. “Un-African” African sexualities: Post-colonial

nation building and the conditioning of citizenship in

sub-Saharan Africa with Analysis of Uganda and

Kenya. Central European University. 2010. In

https://www.etd.ceu.edu/2020/brimmer_jesse.pdf

Adams LA and Govender K. “Making a perfect man”:

Traditional masculine ideology and perfectionism

among adolescent boys. South African Journal of

Psychology. 2008; 38(3): 551-562

Baker G and Ricardo C. Young men and the construction of

masculinity in Sub-Saharan Africa: Implications for

HIV/AIDS, conflict, and violence. Washington, DC:

World Bank. 2005: p.27

Council of Europe. Discrimination on the grounds of sexual

orientation and gender identity in Europe (2nd Eds).

Jouve, Paris: Council of Europe Publishing. 2011

Chavaula MP, Zulu JM and Hurtig AK. Factors influencing

the integration of comprehensive sexuality education

into educational systems in low-and middle-income

countries: a systematic review. Reproductive Health.

; 19(1):196

Malonda E, Llorca A, Zarco A, Samper P and Mestre MV.

Linking traditional masculinity, aggression, and

violence. In Martin C (Eds.). Handbook of anger,

aggression and violence. Switzerland: Springer

Nature, 2022: 2-26

Malonda-Vidal E, Samper-Garcia P, Llorca-Mestre A,

Munoz-Navarro R and Mestre-Escriva V. Traditional

masculinity and aggression in adolescence: Its

relationship with emotional processes. International

Journal of Environmental Research and Public

health.

;18:

,

https://jdoi.org/10.3390/ijerph18189802

Jewkes R, Jordan E, Myrttinen H and Gibbs A. Masculinities

and violence: using latent class analysis to investigate

the origins and correlates of differences between men

in the cross-sectional UN multi-country study on men

and violence in Asia and the Pacific. Journal of global

health. 2020;10(2): 1-16

Dier A and Baldwin G. Masculinities and violent extremism.

International Peace Institute and UN security council

counter-terrorism Committee Executive (CTED).

https://www.ipinst.org/wp

content/uploads/2022/06/Masculinities-and-VE

Web.pdf

Ademuson AO. Women domination and oppression in

Nigerian society: Implications for sustainable

development. African Journal for the psychological

study of social issues. 2016; 19(1): 24-36.

Uduma DO. Igbo women and political development in

Nigeria: Historical perspective. Journal of Research

in Education and Society. 2015; 6(1): 66-72.

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.