Gamete donation—A review of ethical and legal issues

Ijeoma V. Ezeome

Abstract

Sperm and oocytes are building blocks in assisted reproduction. Sperm and ovum donation permit separation of the biological act of producing a child from the psychological process of nurturing and raising the child. However, the art of obtaining and use of these gametes are fraught with ethical and legal challenges. Relevant aspects concerning anonymity, genetic screening, consanguinity, informed consent and risk disclosure, compensation for donors, and child welfare are discussed. Though the issue of anonymity remains controversial, the importance of the welfare of the offspring has come to the fore as a result of the debate. Calls for more rigorous genetic testing for donated gametes to avoid genetic disease transmission, though supported by the principle of beneficence, has to be balanced by its possible deleterious effects on the donors and their relatives especially if findings reveal a serious genetic risk that has no medical treatment as yet. Reimbursement for direct and indirect costs, as well as fair compensation for time lost, inconveniences and risks suffered during treatment is recommended for oocyte donors. The risk of consanguinity remains a problem across the world even though the different guidelines limiting the number of pregnancies by a single gamete may be helpful, if enforceable. It is important that egg donors be clearly made to understand in simple language during the informed consent process of the yet unknown health risks involved so that the consent can be truly voluntary. This will protect donors from the backlash of the doctrine of “Volenti Non Fit Injuria”. It is also suggested that specific legislation with regards to gamete donation, parenthood, and ART should be passed in countries where these are absent, to avoid controversies that may arise due to current gaps in the law. (Afr J Reprod Health 2022; 26[3]: 124-135).

Full Text:

PDF

References

Bahamondes L and Makuch MY. Infertility care and the introduction of new reproductive technologies in poor resource settings. Reprod Biol Endocrinol 2014; 12:8

Mascarenhas MN, Flaxman SR, Boerma T, Vanderpoel S and Stevens GA. National, Regional, and Global Trends in Infertility Prevalence Since 1990: A Systematic Analysis of 277 Health Surveys. PLoS Med 2012; 9(12): e1001356.

Puscheck EE. Infertility. Medscape Jan. 30 2020. Downloaded from https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/274143-overview#showall on 6/10/2020

Kim J. Female education and its impact on fertility. IZA World of Labor 2016: 228

Heng BC. Legal and ethical issues in the international transaction of donor sperm and eggs. J of Ass Reprod Gen. 2007; 24:107–9.

Mackenzie SC, Wickins-Drazilova D and Wickins J. The ethics of fertility treatment for same-sex male couples: considerations for a modern fertility clinic. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 2020; 244:71-5.

Daar J, Benward J, Collins L, Davis J, Davis O, Francis L, Gates E, Gitlin S, Ginsburg E, Klipstein S, McCullough L, Reindollar R, Ryan G, Sauer M, Tipton S and Westphal L. Informing offspring of their conception by gamete or embryo donation: a committee opinion. Fertil Steril 2018; 109:601–5.

Freeman T. Gamete donation, information sharing and the best interests of the child: an overview of the psychosocial evidence. Monash Bioeth Rev. 2015; 33(1): 45–63.

MacCallum F and Keely S. Disclosure patterns of embryo donation mothers compared with adoption and IVF. Reprod Biomed Online 2012; 24 (7) 745-8.

Ezugwu EC, Eleje GU, Iyoke CA, Mba SG, Nnaji HC, Enechukwu IC and Nkwo PO. Preference for anonymity in sperm donation for artificial insemination: an experience from low resource settings in Nigeria. Patient Preference and Adherence 2018;12: 499-504.

Freeman T, Jadva V, Kramer W and Golombok S. Gamete donation: parents’ experiences of searching for their child’s donor siblings and donor. Hum Reprod 2009; 24 (3): 505–16.

Golombok S, Murray C, Javda V, Lycett E, MacCallum F and Rust J. Non-genetic and non-gestational parenthood: consequences for parent–child relationships and the psychological well-being of mothers, fathers and children at age 3. Hum Reprod 2006; 21 (7): 1918–24

Ravelingien A and Pennings G. The Right to Know Your Genetic Parents: From Open-Identity Gamete Donation to Routine Paternity Testing, The Am J Bioethics 2013;13(5): 33-41.

Turkmendarg I. The Donor conceived Child’s Right to Personal Identity: The Public Debate on Donor Anonymity in the United Kingdom. J Law Soc 2012; 39 (1): 58-75.

Ravitsky V. "Knowing Where You Come From": The Rights of Donor-Conceived Individuals and the Meaning of Genetic Relatedness Minn. J.L. Sci. & Tech 2010; 11 (2): 665-84.

Frith, L. Gamete donation and anonymity: the ethical and legal debate. Hum Reprod 2001; 16. (5): 818-824.

United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child UNICEF1989 Downloaded from https://digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/child on 08/10/2020.

Ravelingien A, Provoost V and Pennings G. Open-Identity Sperm Donation: How Does Offering Donor-Identifying Information Relate to Donor-Conceived Offspring’s Wishes and Needs? Bioethical Inquiry 2015; 12:503–9.

Warnock M. 1984. Report of the committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilization and Embryology. Department of Health and Social Security (HMSO), London.

Readings J, Blake L, Casey P, Jadva V and Golombok S. Secrecy, disclosure and everything in-between: decisions of parents of children conceived by donor insemination, egg donation and surrogacy. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 2011; 22: 485 –95.

Harper JC, Kennett D and Reisel D. The end of donor anonymity: how genetic testing is likely to drive anonymous gamete donation out of business. Hum Reprod 2016; 31 (6): 1135-40.

Carborne J. Legal Applications of the “Best Interest of the Child” Standard: Judicial Rationalization or a Measure of Institutional Competence? Pediatrics 2014;134: S111–S120.

Warnock M. 1987. The Good of the Child. Bioethics 2: 141-155.

Greenfeld DA. The impact of disclosure on donor gamete participants: donors, intended parents and offspring. Curr Opinn Obstet Gynecol 2008; 20 (3): 265-8.

Raes I, Ravelingien A and Pennings G. The right of the donor to information about children conceived from his or her gametes. Human Reproduction 2013; 28 (3): 560–5.

Johnson KM. Fertility clinic, egg donation agency, and sperm bank Policies. Fertil Steril 2011; 96:877–9.

Jadva V, Casey P, Readings J, Blake L and Golombok S. A longitudinal study of recipients’ views and experiences of intra-family egg donation. Hum Reprod 2011; 26 (10): 2777–82.

Amato P, Brzyski R, Braverman A, Benward J, Stein A, Steinbock B, Wilder B, Reindollar R, Lamb D, Robertson J, Daar J, Francis L, Gibson M, Fisseha S, Ralston S, Sauer M, Spillman M, Rebar R and Tipton S. Using family members as gamete donors or surrogates. Fertil Steril 2012; 98: 797-803.

Akintola SO and Egbokhare OO. 2018. Parenthood: Is the law in Nigeria fit for assisted reproductive technology? Indian J Med Ethics 2018; 3. (2): 107-13.

Gong D, Liu Y, Zheng Z1, Tian Y and Li Z. 2009. An overview on ethical issues about sperm donation. Asian Journal of Andrology 11: 645–652.

FIGO Committee for the Study of Ethical Aspects of Human Reproduction and Women’s Health. Ethical Issues In Obstetrics and Gynecology. London: FIGO House; 2006.

Sawyer N. Prospective application of a five-step regulatory assessment model to a proposed federal sperm donor registry in Australia: Is it in the public interest? JLM 2010; 17 (1): 1-9.

Marvel S. “Tony Danza is my Sperm Donor?” Queer Kinship and the Impact of Canadian Regulation around Sperm Donation. Can J Women Law 2013; 25 (2): 221-48.

Gong D and Li Z. Sperm donation and sperm bank management In Schenker JG (ed) Ethical dilemmas in Assisted Reproductive Technologies De Gruyter 2011; 87-94.

ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law, de Wert G, Dondorp W, Pennings G, Shenfield F, Devroey P, Tarlatzis B, Barri P and Diedrich K. Intrafamilial medically assisted reproduction: ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law. Hum Reproduction 2011 0(0):1–6.

Janssens PMW, Petra T, Castilla JA, Frith L, Crawshaw M, Mochtar M, Bjorndal L, Kvist U and Kirkman-Brown JC. Evolving minimum standards in responsible international sperm donor offspring quota. Reprod BioMed Online 2015; (30): 568–80.

Dondorp W, De Wert G, Pennings G, Shenfield F, Devroey P, Tarlatzis B, Barri P, Diedrich K, Eichenlaub-Ritter U, Tüttelmann F and Provoost V. ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law21: genetic screening of gamete donors: ethical issues. Human Reproduction 2014; 29. (7): 1353–59.

Kovac JR, Addai J, Smith RP, Coward RM, Lamb DY and Lipshultz LI. The effects of advanced paternal age on fertility. Asian J Androl 2013; 15 (6): 723-8.

Cariati F, D’Argenio V and Tomaiuolo R. The evolving role of genetic tests in reproductive medicine. J Transl Med 2019; 17: 267

Musci TJ and Moyer K. 2010. Prenatal carrier testing for fragile X: counseling issues and challenges. In: Gregg AR. and Simpson JL. (eds). Genetic screening and counseling. Obstet Gynecol Clin North America 2010; 37:61–70.

Bream KD and Lott JP. Heritable disease and sperm donation. Journal of the American Medical Association 2010; 303: 617–18.

Siffroi JP, Charron P and Bujan L. Heritable disease and sperm donation. J Am Med Assoc 2010; 303: 617.

van El CG, Cornel MC, Borry P, Hastings RJ, Fellmann F, Hodgson SV, Howard HC, Cambon-Thomsen A, Knoppers BM, Meijers-Heijboer H, Scheffer H, Tranebjaerg L, Dondorp W and de Wert GMWR, on behalf of the ESHG Public and Professional Policy Committee. Whole-genome sequencing in health care. Recommendations of the European Society of Human Genetics. Eur J Hum Gen 2013; 21. (1): S1–S5.

Lenk C and Beier K. Is the commercialization of human tissue and body material forbidden in the countries of the European Union J Med Ethics 2011; 38 (6): 342-6.

Bayefsky MJ, De Cherney AH and Berkman BE. Compensation for Egg Donation: A Zero-Sum Game. Fertil Steril 2016; 105 (5): 1153-4.

Klitzman RL and Sauer MV. Kamakahi vs ASRM and the future of compensation for human eggs. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2015; 213. (2): 186–187.

Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine. 2007. Financial compensation of oocyte donors. Fertility and Sterility. 88:305–9. [PubMed: 17448470]

Brandt R, Wilkinson S and Williams N. The Donation and Sale of Human Eggs and Sperm. Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy 2017. Downloaded from plato.stanford.edu/entries/gametes-donation-sale on 8/10/2020

Kenney NJ and McGowan ML. Egg donation compensation: ethical and legal challenges. Medicolegal and Bioethics 2014; 4: 15-24.

Kenney NJ and McGowan ML. Looking back: egg donors’ retrospective evaluations of their motivations, expectations, and experiences during their first donation cycle. Fertil Steril 2010; 93 (2):455–66.

Robertson JA. Egg freezing and egg banking: empowerment and alienation in assisted reproduction. Journal of Law and the Biosciences 2014; 2:113–16.

Haimes E, Taylor K and Turkmendag I. Eggs, Ethics and Exploitation? Investigating women experiences of an egg sharing scheme. Sociol Health Illn 2012; 34 (8): 1199-1214.

Tulay P and Atilan O. Oocyte donors’ awareness on donation procedure and risks: A call for developing guidelines for health tourism in oocyte donation programmes. J Turk Ger Gynecol Ass 2019; 20: 236-42.

Schaefer GO, Sinaii N and Graady C. Informing egg donors of the potential for embryonic research: A survey of consent forms from US IVF clinics. Fertil Steril 2012; 9 (2): 427-33.

Baia I, de Freitas C, Samorinha C, Provoost V and Silva S. Dual consent? Donors and Recipients’ views about involvement in decision-making in the use of embryos created by gamete donation in research. BMC Med Ethics 2019; 20: 90.

Niemiec E and Howard HC. Germline Genome Editing Research: What Are Gamete Donors (Not) Informed About in Consent Forms? The CRISPR J 2020; 3 (1): 52-63.

Amato P, Brzyski R, Andrea B, Bennard J, Stein A, Steinbock B et al. Informed Consent and the Use of gametes for Research: a committee opinion. Fertil Steril 2014; 10 (2): 332-5.

Lindheim SR, Coyne K, Ayensu-Coker L, O’Leary K, Sinn S and Jaeger AS. The Impact of Assisted Reproduction on Socio-Cultural Values and Social Norms. Advances in Anthropology 2014; 4:227-42.

De La Cruz D. Should Young women sell their eggs? The New York Times Oct 20 2016.

Vera DA, R-Egg-Ulation: A Call for Greater Regulation of the Big Business of Human Egg Harvesting, 23 Mich J Gender Law 2016; 23: 391- 424.

Braverman A, Steinbock B, Wilder B, Batzer F, Robertson J, Francis L, Gibson M, Amato P, Brzyski R, Rebar R, McClure R, Fisseha S, Farrell R and Lyerly A. Ethics Committee Report. Interests, Obligations and Rights of the donor in gamete donation. Fertil Steril 2009; 91: 22-7.

Beauchamp TL and Childress JF (eds). Principles of Biomedical Ethics 7th ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 2013.

Tober D, Garibaldi C, Blair A and Baltzell K. Alignment between expectations and experiences of egg donors: what does it mean to be informed. Reprod Biomed Soc Online 2021; 12:1-13

Schneider C, Lahl J and Kramer W. Long-term breast cancer risk following ovarian stimulation in young egg donors: a call for follow-up research and informed consent. Reprod BioMed Online 2017; 34: 480-5.

Durrell J. Women’s Eggs: Exceptional Endings. Hastings Women’s Law J 2011; 22(1): 187-230.

Sakshi R. Volenti Non Fit Injuria. Law Times J 2018; October 6. https://lawtimesjournal.in/volenti-non-fit-injuria/#

Fisseha S and Clark NA. Assisted Reproduction for Postmenopausal Women. Am Med Assoc J Ethics 2014; 16 (1): 5-9

Cutas D and Smajdor A. Postmenpausal Motherhood Reloaded: Advanced Age and In Vitro Derived Gametes. Hypathia 2015; 30 (2): 386-402.

Halcomb L. What counts as Family? Gamete donation and construction of family forms in medical markets. J Fam Iss 2020; 41 (6): 831-52.

Okser S, Pahikkala T and Aittokallio T. Genetic variants and their interactions in disease risk prediction - machine learning and network perspectives. Bio-Data Min 2013; 6: 5.

Kool E, van der Graaf R, Bos A, Fauser B and Bredenoord A. What constitutes a reasonable compensation for non-commercial oocyte donors: an analogy with living organ donation and medical research participation. J Med Ethics 2019; 45: 736-741.

Alberta HB, Berry RM and Levine AD. Risk Disclosure and the Recruitment of Oocyte Donors: Are Advertisers Telling the Full Story. JLM Ethics 2014; 232-243.

Pennings G, Vayena E and Ahuja K. Balancing ethical criteria for the recruitment of gamete donors. In: Richards M, Pennings G and Appleby JB. (Ed.) Reproductive Donation: Practice, Policy, and Bioethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012, 150-167.

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.