Who Gets Scarce Medical Resources during a COVID-19 Pandemic? Let’s not beat about the Bush

Polychronis P. Voultsos

Abstract

Except for such rare situations where it might be determined absence of physician’s imputability, physicians cannot ‘save the most lives while respecting the legal rights of the patient’ without violating the overarching principle ‘every human life has equal value’.  Arguing to the contrary is a conscious hypocritical attitude, or in other words, a fiction. Medical law and ethics long since carry with its various fictions. Furthermore, in a public health emergency such as the current COVID-19 crisis, medical law and ethics change and shift the focus from the patient-centered model towards the public health-centered model. Under these particular circumstances, this fiction becomes striking, and it can no longer be swept under the rug. As health emergencies can happen anywhere, anytime, the patient prioritization in circumstances of limited resources should be accepted. Medical law and ethics should back away from strict commitment to placing paramount emphasis on the value of human life. It is time for medical law and ethics to leave taboo-related hypocritical attitudes, and venture to make a historic compromise. To do so, three principles should be met: subsidiarity, proportionality, and consensus and social proof. (Afr J Reprod Health 2020 (Speciial Edition); 24[2]: 32-40).

Full Text:

PDF

References

Epstein M. Legal and institutional fictions in medical

ethics: a common, and yet largely overlooked, phenomenon. J Med Ethics. 2007; 33(6): 362-4.

O’Neill O. Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics.

Cambridge University Press, 2002.

Voultsos P. [The penal problematic of euthanasia].

Athens-Komotini: A. Sakkoulas, 2006, pp: 842-879 [in Greek].

Psaroulis D and Voultsos P. [Medical Law. Elements of

Bioethics]. Thessaloniki: University Studio Press 2010, pp: 359-410 [in Greek].

Hanack E-W. Grenzen artzlicher Behandlungspflicht bei

schwerstgeschadigten Neugeborenen aus juristischer Sicht. MedR 1985: 1: 33-38. [article in German].

Binding K and Hoche A. Die Freigabe der Vernichtung

lebensunwerten Lebens. Leipzig: Meiner Verlag, 1922.

Charalambakis A. [Criminal Law and Courts

Jurisprudence] 2nd edition, Athens: Nomiki Vivliothiki, 2019, p: 513-519 [in Greek].

Vathiotis K. In Charalambakis A. (ed.). [Criminal Law.

Volume I]. Athens: Nomiki Vivliothiki, 2nd edition, 2014, p: 328-330, 333,334, lateral numbers 94-95, 111, 113, 114,115.

Council of Misdemeanours Judges of Athens (Greece),

No 3654/1992, Legal Information Data Base ‘NOMOS’. [in Greek].

Bekas I. [The protection of life and health in penal code].

Athens: P.N. Sakkoulas, 2004, pp: 109, 125-126 [in Greek].

Farsedakis I and Saltanis C, [Introduction in General

Criminal Law], Athens: Nomiki Vivliothiki, 2003, pp: 196-197 note 339. [in Greek].

Kent L. “Tragic Dilemmas, Virtue Ethics and Moral

Luck” (2008). Philosophy Ph.D. Dissertations. 17.

https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/philosophy_diss/17 Accessed: April 25, 2020.

Mannelli C. Whose life to save. Scarce resources

allocation in the COVID-19 outbreak. J Med Ethics. 2020 Apr 9. pii: medethics-2020-106227. doi: 10.1136/medethics-2020-106227. [Epub ahead of print]

Liddell K, Skopek JM, Palmer S, Martin S, Anderson J

and Sagar A. Deciding who gets the ventilator: Will some lives be lost unlawfully? Posted on April 12, 2020 J Med Ethics. Blog. https://blogs.bmj.com/medical-ethics/2020/04/12/deciding-who-gets-the-ventilator-will-some-lives-be-lost-unlawfully/ Accessed: April 25, 2020.

Androulakis N. [Criminal Law. General Part. Volume I],

Athens: P.N. Sakkoulas. 2006, pp: 442-443.

Council of Misdemeanours Judges of Kalamata (Greece),

No 50/2015, Legal Information Data Base ‘NOMOS’. [in Greek].

Kostaras A. Criminal Law. [Concepts and Institutions of

the General Part]. Athens: Nomiki Vivliothiki. 2019 p: 441 [in Greek].

Emanuel EJ, Persad G, Upshur R, Thome B, Parker M,

Glickman A, Zhang C, Boyle C, Smith M and Phillips JP. Fair Allocation of Scarce Medical Resources in the Time of Covid-19. N Engl J Med. 2020 Mar 23. doi: 10.1056/NEJMsb2005114. [Epub ahead of print].

Fortes PA and Pereira PCA. Patient prioritization in

medical emergencies: an ethical analysis. Revista da

Associação Médica Brasileira, 2012; 58(3): 335-340.

Berlinger N, Wynia M, Tia Powell T, Micah Hester M,

Aimee Milliken A, Rachel Fabi R, Felicia Cohn F, Guidry-Grimes LK, Jamie Carlin Watson JC, Lori Bruce L, Chuang EJ, Oei G, Abbott J and Jenks NP. Ethical Framework for Health Care Institutions & Guidelines for Institutional Ethics Services Responding to the Coronavirus Pandemic The Hastings Center, March 16, 2020 https://www.thehastingscenter.org/ethicalframeworkcovid19/ Accessed: April 25, 2020.

De Panfilis L, Tanzi S and Costantini M. The challenge

of providing personalized care under COVID-19. Posted on April 20, 2020. J Med Ethics. Blog. https://blogs.bmj.com/covid-19/2020/04/21/the-challenge-of-providing-personalized-care-under-covid-19/ Accessed: April 25, 2020.

DeMarco JP. Principlism and moral dilemmas: a new

principle. J Med Ethics 2005; 31(2): 101-5.

Koonin LM, Pillai S, Kahn EB, Moulia D and Patel A.

Strategies to Inform Allocation of Stockpiled Ventilators to Healthcare Facilities During a Pandemic. Health Secur. 2020 Mar/Apr;18(2):69-74. doi: 10.1089/hs.2020.0028. Epub 2020 Mar 20.

Phua J, Weng L, Ling L, Egi M, Lim CM, Divatia JV,

Shrestha BR, Arabi YM, Ng J, Gomersall CD, Nishimura M, Koh Y and Du B; Asian Critical Care Clinical Trials Group. Intensive care management of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): challenges and recommendations. Lancet Respir Med. 2020 Apr 6. pii: S2213-2600(20)30161-2. [Epub ahead of print] Review.

Daugherty Biddison EL, Faden R, Gwon HS, Mareiniss

DP, Regenberg AC, Schoch-Spana M, Schwartz J and Toner ES. Too Many Patients…A Framework to Guide Statewide Allocation of Scarce Mechanical Ventilation During Disasters. Chest. 2019 Apr;155(4):848-854.

Nicoli F and Gasparetto A. Italy in a Time of Emergency

and Scarce Resources: The Need for Embedding Ethical Reflection in Social and Clinical Settings. J Clin Ethics. 2020 Spring;31(1):92-94.

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.